• Excerpt from Chapter 2: Life in New York and the End of the Emigration

History has characterized Aaron Burr as undeniably one of the most bizarre and sinister men in American history. However, the evidence of his relationship with Theodosia and Natalie, and the manner in w hich he conducted his household, points to a gentle, warm, and caring father.

He was a responsible and strong influence for both of them. Theodosia, an only child, was vulnerable to emotional insecurity as a result of her mother's untimely death. He also offered enormous support for Natalie, who came into his household in the midst of much insecurity and uncertainty created by her involuntary exile at the tender age of eleven years.

Burr sustained Natalie and Madame Senat for the eight years of their exile. He spent as much time as he possibly could with both the girls. His close, nurturing, and fatherly warmth continued until Theodosia's marriage to Joseph Alston, a prominent South Carolina planter and politician. When Theodosia moved with her husband to South Carolina, Natalie remained in New York and maintained her close relationship with Burr, and he kept in close contact with Theodosia through frequent exchanges of letters.

Natalie became a sister for Theodosia and a daughter for Aaron Burr. The intimate relationship she developed and enjoyed with the Burrs undoubtedly eased much of the uncertainty and unsteadiness she felt during the early days of her life in New York. She became fluent and proficient in the English language and in many respects became an American during these formative years of her life.